Release

With band members all around 60 years old a band could be forgiven if they decided to start taking it easy. Metallica have many roads available to them when they create music these days, and it felt like they had settled into a nice comfy pattern of 'not too heavy, not too light' with Hardwired To Self-Destruct. Turns out they still have a surprise or two in them yet, as 72 Seasons is the heaviest and most unrelenting album they have ever created. This is a dark album, and as each song rolls by you appreciate the many layers of texture this band have become the masters of laying down. For the most part it is pedal-to-the-floor fast, with little room for air between the songs and riffs, leaving a feeling of suffocation or even claustrophobia that Metallica don't normal conjure. There isn't a ballad or even a clear guitar, but did we need one? Slayer or Exodus never looked back and wished they had written 'Nothing Else Matters', because sometimes you just want intensity when the subject matter calls for it. Standouts for me are '72 Seasons', 'Crown Of Barbed Wire', and 'Room Of Mirrors'. There are riffs everywhere, and the only low points here are a couple of repetitions too many on the slower songs. This will probably not be the album some people wanted or expected, including me - but now that it is in my ears I couldn't imagine anything else I'd want more from Metallica circa 2023.

I have thought of a number of ways to address this review. Loving, accepting, scathing? I'm in the middle of the latter 2. There is very little I like about this release and a lot I don't like. 'Lux Eterna' is a killer track and deserves a place on any record from them up until now. Additionally, across most songs, A-plus rating to Kirk and his solos. The best as a collective I have heard for a long time. What I don't like - why was Rob not given an opportunity to shine, present an intro or something like he has in the past? Very disappointing. As for Lars, apart from 'Lux Eterna', he's hardly asked to move out of second gear. Useful I suppose if they play into their 80's. He'll have no trouble. Finally I read about the maturity and sincerity of James' lyrics and how personal they are. I have never listened like a Rhodes scholar into the meaning of his lyrics. That's not the reason I listen to music for. His singing of the chorus on a number of songs is cringe worthy. The title song is sloppy with his singing of Wrath of man in the chorus. He has never sung like that!! Finally a 11 minute song at the end when we are already 66 mins in. And it's not your typical Metallica last track. Slow paced and boring (apart from Kirk which as I said is the star of this record). Quality over quantity please. I've come to accept that I loved Hardwired ...To Self-Destruct so much, particularly it's variety per song, that this record is a step down and for the most part is a rock band playing stock music. Never thought I'd say that.