|
TheBigBlack's Rock Top 10 |
|
|
|
The Yardbirds
|
|
|
|
Simon & Garfunkel
|
|
|
|
The Animals
|
|
|
|
Bob Dylan
|
|
|
|
The Rolling Stones
|
|
The debate of The Beatles vs The Stones has ranged for over half a century, and will no doubt continued unresolved for many years yet. Comparisons are rife, but to be fair - remove the relativity of timing and location, and there really isn't much you can compare. The Beatles debut was full of Rock 'n' Roll with a little bit of R&B, and The Rolling Stones introduced themselves to the world with a little bit of R&B and a whole lot of blues. Most album (and career) openers burst out the speakers untamed, but The Stones instead introduce their debut album with the restrained 'Route 66'. A cover of the King Cole Trio, it is the sound of vintage America wrapped in the comfy blanket of London's swinging 60s. In case you are question the authenticity of white boys playing the blues, next up is the Muddy Waters classic 'I Just Want To Make Love To You' nailed in a wonderful, fast paced rock 'n' roll style that is totally The Stones. Jimmy Reed's 'Honestly I Do' finally puts to bed the comparison's with the Fab Four. Whereas The Beatles would perform a song like this with charm that would cause the teenage girls to faint, the sleaze of The Stones starts to creep in untamed. Mick Jagger isn't singing to school girls, he is singing to women. Bo Diddly's 'Mona' is a pretty faithful rendition, as you can't really perform a Diddly song without that distinctive rhythm. Most of these songs are covers, and the three tracks written by the band quickly reveal why. 'Now I Got A Witness' is a flat instrumental that has no real purpose, and 'Tell Me (You're Coming Back)' manages to redeem itself with a sniff of sixty's charm. 'Little By Little' is the only song of the three that hints at the future potential as a band of songwriters, and although it is credited to the whole band it reeks of that Mick Jagger / Keith Richards style that would become so prominent later. Song after song the album drips with atmosphere that makes it hard to deny. Recorded in and mixed only in true mono, it has a flatness to the sound that gives it an air of authenticity of its purpose, showcasing the great blues of the U.S.A. Slim Harpo's 'I'm A King Bee' is just perfect in its execution, with some great lead work by Brian Jones, and it sets up side 2 to rival the first. Chuck Berry's 'Carol' is played in a very Berry style, and is perhaps a little too. 'sterile' to rival the original. Many of the early Stones recordings suffer from poor sound quality due to the band's insistence of working outside the Decca studios, but this album is pristine in its sonics. It all ends nicely with a fairly basic and almost quaint version of Rufus Thomas' 'Walking The Dog', leaving you with just enough energy to go back to track 1 and start it all over again. Popularity at the time aside (the album topped the U.K. charts for 12 weeks) in hindsight it can be said it is a slow and steady start to a career that would certainly ramp up in the future. There are hints of potential throughout, but you won't find any of that signature Stones swagger that came to be such a identifying trait later. Regardless, it is a wonderful time capsule back to a time when music was simpler, but no less essential. |
|
The Beatles
|
|
|
|
Bob Dylan
|
|
|
|
The Beatles
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Last Data Update: | Site Updates | File Tagging Standards
Contact TheBigBlack | © 2018-2026 TheBigBlackMachine.com
Mediabase 2.0 is a new version of the site being rebuilt, page by page, line by line. Same old look, but with a new engine. You may see an error or two, but don't worry - it will all run smoothly soon.
In the meantime Mediabase 1.0 is still available here.